Ranked #2 of 86 for Best Pizza
I almost didn't want to vote for them because I don't want anybody else taking up all the spots at the best pizza place around!
Vote: BEST Pizza
You never know when Pewaukee native JJ Watt may show up to pick up a pizza...or two.
Absolutely amazing pizza. But you need to ask them for just an extra drizzle of cheese on top to hold all the toppings on!
They've kept their traditional recipe. I love that!
Something about their sauce is just incredible and the toppings are always piled on!!
There isn't a better pie anywhere!!!!
Great pizza! Great people! Go there now!
New Owner is a great guy.
Best Pizza EVER!!!!!! Perfect atmosphere for any occasion.
The 2017 Milwaukee A-List awards are based on more than 55,000 votes from local Milwaukee-area experts.
See the full results →
Best Wedding Flowers ⋅
Best Italian ⋅
Best Romantic Restaurant ⋅
Best Martial Arts ⋅
Best Sports Bar
Connect with Milwaukee A-List
© CityVoter, Inc.