Cakes - Best of 2012

Published Jan 4, 2013

Buttercream or fondant? Where would you go for your dream wedding cake?

2012 Winner

1. Simma's Bakery

Voters Love

"Simma's uses only the Finest Ingredients for everything. Always the same consistent quality and fair priced. I buy..." via Jim F.

Find It
817 North 68th Street Milwaukee WI 53213
  • Simma's Bakery, Weddings, Specialty Food and Drink, Cakes, Caterer, Wedding Cakes, Bakery, 817 North 68th Street World Map Milwaukee WI 53213
    Nominee for: Cakes
    817 North 68th Street, World Map Milwaukee, WI
  • Aggie's Bakery and Cake Shop, Weddings, Cakes, Wedding Cakes, 7328 W. Greenfield ave World Map West Allis WI 53214
    Nominee for: Cakes
    7328 W. Greenfield ave, World Map West Allis, WI
  • Bettersweet Bakery, Weddings, Cakes, N6947 Jennifer Dr Plymouth WI 53073
    Nominee for: Cakes
    N6947 Jennifer Dr, Plymouth, WI
  • Brookfield Wedding Cakes, Weddings, Cakes, 14440 W Lisbon Rd Brookfield WI 53005
    Nominee for: Cakes
    14440 W Lisbon Rd, Brookfield, WI
  • Rich's House of Cakes, Weddings, Cakes, Wedding Cakes, 4353 S 27th St World Map Milwaukee WI 53221
    Nominee for: Cakes
    4353 S 27th St, World Map Milwaukee, WI
  • Nominee for: Cakes
    Bilgos Court, Plymouth, WI
  • The Cake Lady and Petite Pastries, Weddings, Cakes, Wedding Cakes, 3561 S Kinnickinnic Ave World Map Saint Francis WI 53235
    Nominee for: Cakes
    3561 S Kinnickinnic Ave, World Map Saint Francis, WI
  • Cake and Bake, Weddings, Cakes, W164 N11271 Squire Dr Germantown WI 53022
    Nominee for: Cakes
    W164 N11271 Squire Dr, Germantown, WI
  • Eat Cake, Weddings, Cakes, Wedding Cakes, 4303 W Vliet St Martin Drive Milwaukee WI 53208
    Nominee for: Cakes
    4303 W Vliet St, Martin Drive Milwaukee, WI
  • Cakes by Erin Salerno, Weddings, Cakes, Wedding Cakes, 18900 W Bluemound Rd Brookfield WI 53045
    Nominee for: Cakes
    18900 W Bluemound Rd, Brookfield, WI
  • Le Cakery, Weddings, Cakes, 13320 Watertown Plank Rd Elm Grove WI 53122
    11. Le Cakery
    Nominee for: Cakes
    13320 Watertown Plank Rd, Elm Grove, WI
  • Creations for the Moment, Weddings, Cakes, 5620 S Aberdeen Dr New Berlin WI 53146
    Nominee for: Cakes
    5620 S Aberdeen Dr, New Berlin, WI
  • Delicately Delicious, Weddings, Cakes, Wedding Cakes, N56 W6393 Center Street Cedarburg WI 53012
    Nominee for: Cakes
    N56 W6393 Center Street, Cedarburg, WI
  • Cakes By Stephanie, Weddings, Cakes, Bette Dr Menomonee Falls WI 53051
    Nominee for: Cakes
    Bette Dr, Menomonee Falls, WI
  • Gourmet Cheesecake Shop & More, Weddings, Cakes, 1329 S 70th St Milwaukee WI 53214
    Nominee for: Cakes
    1329 S 70th St, Milwaukee, WI
  • Regina's Bay Bakery, Weddings, Cakes, 423 E Silver Spring Dr Whitefish Bay WI 53217
    Nominee for: Cakes
    423 E Silver Spring Dr, Whitefish Bay, WI
  • Nominee for: Cakes
    South Milwaukee, WI
  • The Extra Special Touch Bakery, Weddings, Cakes, S29 W27308 Green Ln. Waukesha WI 53188
    Nominee for: Cakes
    S29 W27308 Green Ln., Waukesha, WI
  • Greg Soup-Er-Deserts, Weddings, Cakes, Milwaukee Ave South Milwaukee WI 53172
    Nominee for: Cakes
    Milwaukee Ave, South Milwaukee, WI
  • Location
    Nominee for: Cakes
    5607 7th Ave, Kenosha, WI
  • Scordato's Italian Bakery & Deli, Weddings, Cakes, Wedding Cakes, 5011 W Howard Ave World Map Milwaukee WI 53220
    Nominee for: Cakes
    5011 W Howard Ave, World Map Milwaukee, WI
  • Jan's Specialty Cakes, Weddings, Cakes, 9115 W Oklahoma Ave Milwaukee WI 53227
    Nominee for: Cakes
    215 Pine St N, Turtle Lake, WI
  • Sweetness By Alice, Weddings, Cakes,  Milwaukee WI
    Nominee for: Cakes
    East Town Milwaukee, WI
  • Panache Desserts, Weddings, Cakes, 17700 West Capitol Drive Brookfield  WI 53045
    Nominee for: Cakes
    17700 West Capitol Drive, Brookfield , WI
Contest Overview
  • 124,359
    Total Votes
  • 38,063
  • 122

The 2012 A-List awards are based on more than 124,000 votes from local Milwaukee-area experts.

See the full results →

Get more from the Milwaukee A-List
Arts and Entertainment
Cheap Eats
Great Meals
Health and Fitness
Specialty Food and Drink
Contest Tools
Business Owners
Top Voters
FAQs / Help
Contest Rules
How it Works - Deals
CityVoter Blog
The Milwaukee A-List features more than 5,424 businesses competing for title of Milwaukee's best.

Connect with Milwaukee A-List